Suzuka or Ichigo 100%?

blackroseXP · newbie! Joined: Dec 30, 2005 Posts: 8 Location: new york

Ichigo 100%

hyade · Conscript Joined: Mar 25, 2005 Posts: 100 Location: Penang

Ichigo 100% because it has more comedy than Suzuka.
_________________
Remember,PAST FAILURES DO NOT EQUAL FUTURE FAILURE!
In fact PAST FAILURES + LEARNING CAN EQUAL FROM IT FUTERE SUCESS

samishii · Posted: Fri Jan 27, 2006 11:54 am Post subject: Re: Suzuka or Ichigo 100%?

markieboi4ever · Conscript Joined: Jan 04, 2006 Posts: 112

well if we must tell which is better, the vote goes directly to Ichigo 100% since the manga is done, happy or sad but its done already so we know how the story developed all the character and stuff. Personally it was not so predictable as i thought since i was rooting for Aya and that baka. Also that story reminded me my highschool life in every single way, i wasn't on the film club but in the literature one so you may say that i was wrapped by the story since the very beginning Rolling Eyes

.

However Suzuka is not finished yet Sad

, and the story is quite simple, it has a lot of drama. Though I dont know what is it, i think it needs something more Confused

.
Also the story can be way to cool for some guys around here, but wait until its done, hope it doesn't get a crappy end and crush all your hopes Wink

.

Both stories, are nice, but to tell the truth i wasn't so atracted to Suzuka since its more like Love hina in a more realistic story. And in the other side, Ichigo can be taken as one master piece first because i can't think of another story that can fit Ichigo including all the elements of it. Also is pretty catchy and original since the story really captivates you and makes you want to read some more ( well i'm not sure if it does, but man!! you can count all the topics about ichigo and then think about it) and its also a shounen manga made by a girl Shocked

.

So in my experience(since i can relate perfectly to 3/4 of the story to my life Cool

) you can learn from everything even from mistakes, and this manga can be really some help to understand the typical situations that you may face with girls, and look the perspective of a girl. Confused

thats again my own opinion Razz

s070746821 · Heimin (Commoner) Joined: Dec 13, 2005 Posts: 63

We can't judge a series on whether it's complete or not, well we can, but shouldn't

I personally like Suzuka better. I think the artwork is better than Ichigo 100% and Ichigo is more funnier, but frankly I didn't like how Ichigo 100% turned out.

so Suzuka! (But I don't like the fact that Sakurai got dumped)

aznkoolps · Heimin (Commoner) Joined: Jan 24, 2006 Posts: 50

I like suzuka better because I can relate to it so much more. Although it would be "pretty" nice to be surrounded with so many girls who are all crazy about you.

banzemanga · Naginata Ashigaru Joined: Jan 02, 2006 Posts: 405

billion · newbie! Joined: Dec 30, 2005 Posts: 31

i dont agree with u bazenamnga cuz ichigo if we read it many event happen is not logic but suzuka is more realistic

NickKosmo · newbie! Joined: Dec 06, 2005 Posts: 39

True, but I don't read manga because it's realistic. I read because of how good the story is, no matter how impossible it may seem. I like Ichigo better because of hoy many different things could happen at any time. But in Suzuka, there was a time where it looked like she would never like him. And I feel that worsened away the story quite a bit. I mean, he was trying so hard to get Suzuka to notice him and all she wanted to do was ignore him due to the fact the someone she liked passed away.

thanh · newbie! Joined: Sep 06, 2005 Posts: 27 Location: france

i think ichigo 100%!!!Because it's funier than suzuka!

OgReLyNx · Posted: Sun Jan 29, 2006 8:01 am Post subject:

for me personally its Ichigo, its the 1st manga i've read and i can relate to it also, not too mention that the characters had an effect on me as well.. also the storyline is very complex and it kept most of the readers to the egde of their seats. dnt get me wrong thought i like suzuka also but it has less conflicts but it lacks the excitement that Ichigo has

banzemanga · Naginata Ashigaru Joined: Jan 02, 2006 Posts: 405

Yeah I know that Suzuka is realistic and even more than Ichigo 100%. For exmaple, Suzuka and her strange character that sometimes pisses me of but that is the way some girls are and men have to endure. (too bad)

Anyway, I know that Suzuka is a relly good manga but i think that it is yet not better than Ichigo 100% because it can't extract the deep and beautiful emotions within me. If Suzuka can make me cry as much as Ichigo 100% with such tragic drama I will vote for it. But for the mean time, Ichigo 100% rules.

Also Suzuka is not as suspense as Ichig 100%. For readers to like a story should be entertaining and have something to impulse them to keep going on. Suzuka doesn't give me a higher impulse than Ichigo 100%.

ArkImpulse · Heimin (Commoner) Joined: Mar 19, 2005 Posts: 60

I perfer Suzuka, although the anime is longer than Ichigo 100%, I'm not sure about the manga. Ichigo 100% kind of drags the storyline, while Suzuka gets right to the point that Yamato likes Suzuka...

billion · newbie! Joined: Dec 30, 2005 Posts: 31

only suzuka

KaleRylan · Heimin (Commoner) Joined: Jun 10, 2005 Posts: 50

I said Suzuka because the question asked which i can relate to more. Let's face it, as Manaka's friends mention in the manga on several occasions, his situation isn't exactly normal or realistic.

Yeah, maybe the main guy in Suzuka has a strange situation living in the girl's dorm, but it doesn't seem to be that important to the story that he's in the girl's dorm so it doesn't bug me.

Now if the question had simply been which i like better, the answer would probably have been Ichigo, at least so far since i haven't finished suzuka.